Bookmark and Share

Use the Extended Search

Music News on

Can Pirate Bay's new cloud business model succeed?

Wayne Rosso, formerly CEO of Grokster, founder of Maxxbox, and outspoken critic of the Recording Industry Association of America, recently joined Global Gaming Factory, the soon-to-be owner of file-sharing legend The Pirate Bay.

In an interview with CNET's Digital Media blog, Rosso outlined what turns out to be an extremely innovative cloud-computing business model.

The only question is, will it work?

In the interview, Rosso outlines a plan in which The Pirate Bay customers could pay a monthly fee for music service, but could reduce that cost by contributing storage capacity to a commercially available Storage-as-a-Service offering:

For example, a person may dedicate a gig of (storage) space to the network and the fee may go from $9 to $5. (Rosso declined to discuss pricing yet so the numbers are made up just for the example).

"The more of your computer resources you contribute to the network, the less you pay down to zero," Rosso said. "The user is in control."

In other words, The Pirate Bay aims to be the first commercial peer-to-peer storage cloud that separates how capacity is acquired from how it is sold. This is extremely interesting, because it means it can sell one service to a consumer audience (music and video), and another entirely different service to business (storage services).

The implications of this approach are profound. For example, while the model described for The Pirate Bay is a simple one, I can see real opportunity to expand it into a liquid marketplace for storage capacity. Here is how I would do it:


In addition to allowing any music/video customer to reduce their costs by adding their storage capacity to the Pirate Bay cloud, require them to provide critical meta-data (or calculate it), such as location, device type and speed, and so on.

Instead of selling a fixed-price storage offering, auction off specific customer storage units based on that meta-data. Thus, a 7200rpm SAS drive in Kansas would go for much less than, say, a solid-state drive with encryption in the Principality of Sealand. The reasons for the discrepancy would have to do with the speed, security, and regulatory overhead of each storage unit.

Also allow other entrepreneurs and businesses to add specific storage to the network without the music/video subscription, and pay them a cut of the total revenue generated from their storage.

Now build a set of general services, such as replication, deduplication, disaster recovery, etc. into the service as a whole, and sell those as additional subscriptions.

Pretty cool, huh? The problem is, there's a catch.

One of the guiding principals of cloud computing for consumers and the small/medium business market is that the customer will never need to own large amounts of storage again. Thus, there may not be any storage for the average music customer to donate to the Pirate Bay cloud.

I see three possible outcomes for this service as The Pirate Bay defines it today (as opposed to the extended vision I just outlined above):


The Pirate Bay negotiates inclusion of its software into the consumer media server systems being sold in the next year or two. This is the one device where I think most households will own significant storage of their own. If it becomes "point and click" to donate some of that storage in exchange for free or cheap music, The Pirate Bay might find a market.

The Pirate Bay evolves its business plan to take on some or all of the elements I suggested above. This would allow them to acquire capacity through commercial interests wishing to make money from The Pirate Bay's peer-to-peer service.

The Pirate Bay sees an initial interest in its service based on "old school" computer users, but sees a steady decline in customers exchanging storage for music. In the end, the music business succeeds or fails in a highly competitive subscription music market, but the cloud-storage business either collapses or changes its business model to survive.

(I also wonder if the model Rosso describes creates a playground for cybercriminals, both in terms of giving them very anonymous storage options and allowing them potential access to consumer systems through exploits of The Pirate Bay's software.)

Regardless of whether or not The Pirate Bay succeeds in delivering the service Rosso outlined, the concept itself is intriguing and innovative. I certainly can see an auction marketplace for Infrastructure as a Service capabilities appearing from a peer-to-peer model in time. If it does, that will change the face of the cloud market in truly fundamental ways....

by James Urquhart
Source >> (

Recent News:

- Sony Earbuds Stop Playing Music When Removed

- Vodafone Group Signs Music Deal With Warner Music

- Using Smart Playlists With Nested Conditionals in ITunes

- Yoko Ono is on a mission -- still

- Zune HD review: Music wants you back

- Music Industry Wants Apple, Amazon to Pay Up

- Experts Weigh In On Kanye West's Post-VMA Career Recovery

- Twones: Profile aggregation for music

- Fool's Gold a world music don't-miss

- World Music Fest guide


- Sony Earbuds Stop Playing Music When Removed

- Vodafone Group Signs Music Deal With Warner Music

- Using Smart Playlists With Nested Conditionals in ITunes

- Yoko Ono is on a mission -- still

- Zune HD review: Music wants you back

- Music Industry Wants Apple, Amazon to Pay Up

- Experts Weigh In On Kanye West's Post-VMA Career Recovery

- Twones: Profile aggregation for music

- Fool's Gold a world music don't-miss

- World Music Fest guide

- What's with all the public outbursts?

- Janet Jackson leads music and dance tribute to Michael Jackson at MTV VMA

- Stream audio from any application with Airfoil

- 2009 MTV Video Music Awards Premiere Watched By 27 Million Total Viewers Up 17% vs...

- Daft Punk Contribute Music, Masks to DJ Hero

- Pod to PC Migrates Your Music Between iPod and PC--And It's Cheaper Than the Competition

- Court backs ban on religious-based song at graduation

- EU clears Bertelsmann, KKR music rights JV

- VMA Venue Comes To Life: Inside Radio City Music Hall

- What would they think if you sang out of tune? Beatles beget a video game.

- Beaterator impressions: Making music on the PSP

- MTV Brings the Music to the Masses for VMA Weekend 2009

- Comes With Music aims for Spotify

- British Library opens music vault

- Comes With Music not coming to U.S. in 2009

- Music label video site Vevo in talks with CBS, NBC

- Music made for monkeys

- Music celebrity DJ AM found dead at his home

- Apple Approves IPhone Music App

- Internet Age re-inventing music business: Bandwidth

- Can't stop the (free) music

- Wanna be a rock star? Career advice from Jimmy Page, the Edge and Jack White

- UPDATE 1-U.S. FCC examining broadcasters in music fee row

- Three days of mud and music at Woodstock in 1969

- Michael Jackson: a music legend

- Music industry may seek salvation in 'all you can eat' downloads

- Mexico's Rampant Music Piracy A Challenge To Apple's iTunes

- Van's Night of High Artistry Is No Mean Feat

- Bringing back memories

- COLUMN-Has Europe's hottest site got what it takes? Eric Auchard

- Stream music, movies and photos

- iLike App Uses Music to Find Concerts

- Poll: Jackson Will Be Remembered for Music

- RIAA: "All your music are belong to us"

- Happy Hour? "Cocktail" Is All About The Benjamins

- Is music made too much for mass appeal?

- How to load music onto a mobile phone

- MySpace Music's Courtney Holt hints at new features

- Best Ways to Produce Music on an iPhone

- New Mozart piano music discovered

- Can Pirate Bay's new cloud business model succeed?

- Amadou and Mariam: Mali's world music superstars

- Bose SoundLink Wireless Music System streams music from your PC to a portable speaker for $550

- Music industry wants cut of Pirate Bay sale

- Michael Jackson's Unreleased Songs, Continuing the Music Legacy

- MSN shouldn't guide Microsoft's music strategy

- App of the Week: A Rube Goldberg Music Machine

- The Bigger-Band Sounds of a Trance-Music Duo

- More details on instrumental album Michael Jackson started before his death, and his love of classical music

- Music Filesharing Mom Seeks New Trial

- KKR Said to Invest $347 Million in Bertelsmann Music Venture

- Music Labels Reach Royalty Deal for Webcasts

- In Death as in Life, Michael Jackson Sets Music Sales Records

- 10 Milestones in Portable Music

- Twitter Hits Right Notes for Music Industry

- Michael Jackson rewrites online music records

- 90,000 Ravers With Very Few Clothes Break Attendance Record at Electric Daisy Carnival

- A visit to Michael Jackson's childhood home in Indiana

- Denon DJ Unveils DN-X1700

- Youngest DJ world record set by Jack Hill

- DJ breaks record

- Survey reveals that Asian youth are wrapped around music

- Music China - International Trade Fair For Musical Instruments And Services

Join the DataBass for FREE today!

Sign up for in 2 minutes, and enjoy all its advantages for FREE!

star Upload your own mixes (up to 100 MB per File / 300 MB total)
star Your own profile page with pictures and contact details
star Download Podcasts, exclusivly mixed for databass
star Live-Music-Streams for your songs
star The Event Calendar
star Unlimited Membership duration
star MAX up your account to PRO or PRO+ and use databass to its limits. 1 GB storage, unlimited downloads, more advertising, domain: "", mail adress " and more to come!!!

If you have further questions, please read the FAQ or contact our Support. Thank you.


Donate 1$ for

All donations are going towards general maintenance of

If you like our services and find useful for you, please donate towards the project via the PayPal form below. Thank you.